British Berkefeld vs Berkey: What’s the Difference?

 

If you’ve been shopping for a gravity water filter, chances are you’ve come across two big names: British Berkefeld and Berkey. Both brands sell stainless steel countertop systems that look nearly identical, and both claim to make unsafe water safe to drink.

But looks can be deceiving. When it comes to what’s inside the filter and how those claims are verified, there are some very important differences.

This guide will break down British Berkefeld vs Berkey so you can make an informed decision for your home or emergency preparedness kit.

Company Backgrounds

British Berkefeld (Doulton):

  • Manufactured in the UK by Doulton, a company with over 185 years of history in ceramic water filtration.
  • Their filters have been used in hospitals, households, and emergency situations around the world.

Berkey:

  • Launched in the U.S. in the 1990s.
  • Popular in the preparedness and homesteading niche.
  • Built a large following through word-of-mouth, but has faced increasing scrutiny over the last few years.

Filter Media Differences

British Berkefeld Ultra Sterasyl & Ultra Fluoride Filters

  • True ceramic outer shell surrounding a carbon block core.
  • The ceramic layer blocks turbidity and pathogenic cysts.
  • The carbon block reduces chlorine, VOCs, pesticides, herbicides, and more.
  • Available with or without fluoride reduction capability.

Berkey Black Filters

  • Marketed as a “proprietary blend.”
  • Claim to use ceramic, but based on appearance and testing, they look more like a carbon block with no visible ceramic shell.
  • Lack of transparency around what exactly is inside.

Certifications & Testing

Here’s where the two brands really separate:

  • British Berkefeld:
    • Filters are NSF/ANSI-certified for turbidity reduction and cyst removal.
    • Certification means an independent lab has verified the performance claims.
    • Certificates are publicly listed and easy to verify.
  • Berkey:
    • No NSF, WQA, or IAPMO certifications.
    • Rely on their own “independent lab test results,” but these are not the same as accredited certifications.

    • Since 2023, Berkey has been under an EPA stop-sale order in the U.S., meaning their filters cannot be legally sold.

Performance & Lifespan

British Berkefeld:

  • Ultra Sterasyl filters last about 3,000 gallons per pair.
  • Ultra Fluoride filters last about 1,200 gallons per pair.
  • Flow rate can be increased by adding more candles (up to 8 in larger systems).

Berkey:

  • Black filters are advertised as lasting 6,000 gallons per pair, though independent testing to support this is lacking.
  • Fluoride filters (PF-2) have much shorter lifespans, and in some cases have been shown to leach activated alumina into the water if installed incorrectly.

Price & Value

  • Upfront System Cost: Berkey units are typically more expensive than British Berkefeld systems of comparable size.
  • Filter Replacements: Berkefeld ceramic filters are competitively priced and backed by certification. Berkey filters may claim longer lifespan, but without certification it’s hard to verify real-world performance.

Safety & Reliability

  • British Berkefeld: Backed by official certification and a long history of global use. Reliable performance you can verify.
  • Berkey: Attractive marketing, but no certifications, ongoing lawsuits, and regulatory issues.

The Bottom Line

Both British Berkefeld and Berkey sell stainless steel gravity filters that look similar on the outside. But the inside — and the certifications — tell a very different story.

If you want peace of mind that your filter has been independently verified for safety and performance, the choice is clear: British Berkefeld is the more trustworthy option.

👉 Shop British Berkefeld Gravity Filters at The Filterium

 

FAQs

Q1: What’s the difference between British Berkefeld and Berkey filters?
A: British Berkefeld filters are NSF-certified ceramic filters made in the UK, while Berkey filters lack certifications and are currently under an EPA stop-sale order.

Q2: Are British Berkefeld filters NSF certified?
A: Yes, British Berkefeld Ultra Sterasyl filters are NSF-certified for microplastics, particulates, turbidity and cyst reduction, giving verified performance.

Q3: Why is Berkey under an EPA stop-sale order?
A: In 2023, the EPA issued a stop-sale order for Berkey filters due to regulatory concerns. As of now, Berkey cannot legally sell filters in the U.S. (to the best of our knowledge)

Q4: Which gravity water filter lasts longer, Berkey or British Berkefeld?
A: Berkey claims longer lifespans, but without certification these numbers can’t be verified. Berkefeld filters are independently tested and verified for their stated capacity.

Q5: Which is better for emergency preparedness, Berkey or British Berkefeld?
A: British Berkefeld is the safer choice because its filters are certified and globally trusted, making it a reliable option for emergency use.

Back to blog